The Warden opens a bar in Superjail, the Superbar, in an attempt to get a date with Alice. Things take a turn for the worse when Jared falls off the wagon and becomes drunk.

The Warden and his staff unearth an ancient fighting arena. It is reactivated in an effort to decrease the high inmate depression level and becomes a Thunderdome-like chance for the inmates to fight to the death for freedom. The Twins attempt to sabotage the arena with Combaticus, a fighter created from their DNA.

A carrier ship for the female prison "Ultraprison" crash-lands in Superjail. Ultraprison's "Mistress" and the Warden arrange a ball for their inmates as part of a bet to see which set of convicts can act more refined. The Warden gets to keep the female prisoners if he wins the bet; if the Mistress wins, she gets Superjail.

An Ed Gein-like serial killer is mistakenly captured by Jailbot instead of Jacknife, putting Superjail on edge. To investigate his grip on the inmates, the Warden sends Jared undercover as a inmate. When the new arrival accidentally kills himself, Jared takes the credit and becomes admired by inmates as Superjail's most violent resident. Meanwhile, the Twins hack into Jailbot and control him like a video game.

The Warden invites his favorite motivational speaker, D.L. Diamond, to Superjail.

The Warden holds a science fair and declares himself the winner for inventing the Terrorarium, a snowglobe containing miniature jungle filled with dangerous, carnivorous insects.

Jacknife's latest crime results in him accidentally kidnapping a little girl with cancer as Jailbot drags him back to Superjail. A disfigured inmate, discovering it is the girl's birthday, decides to throw her a party. Meanwhile, the Warden conjures his gremlin-like inner child, which tries to kill the girl, as she makes him feel old.

The Warden tries to stop a riot by monitoring the inmates' dreams.

Faced with overcrowding in his prison, the Warden decides to make Superjail into a franchise, but is arrested by the Time Police to stand trial for devastation this decision causes.

With the Warden missing, the Superjail staff tries to make it in the real world. Meanwhile, the inmates of Superjail adopt a peaceful, pastoral lifestyle as they await the Warden's return.